Here's the summary of how the displaced players performed compared with the new guys:
Wake had a decent day. Misi didn't do much. JT recorded a sack and got booed, and got a gatorade shower. J-Peasy got a forced fumble and a sack. Advatange to the old guys.
Greg Camarillo had two catches. Marlon Moore had zip. Small advantage to Camarillo.
And on kick returns, well, the Phins parted ways with their new guy (Smith) and instead used Cobbs and Bess, who were okay. Better than Smith anyway. Ted Ginn, jr, did not play. So advantage to the newer phins.